A Love to Hide is a haunting, gut-wrenching, and heart-breaking love story
by Nevin Jefferson
SGN A&E Writer
A Love to Hide (Un amour à taire)
In French with English Subtitles
102 minutes
Cast: Bruno Todeschini, Charlotte De
Turckheim, Jeremie Renier, Louise
Monot, Michel Jonasz
Director: Christian Faure
Screenwriter: Pascal Fontanille,
Samantha Mazeras
It's springtime in Paris, 1942.
The Nazis have occupied Europe
and chaos and confusion rule.
Handsome Jean (Jérémie Renier,)
is a dutiful son who runs the family
's laundry business during the
day. By night, he's in the arms of
Philippe (Bruno Todeschini), who
is an agent of the resistance.
These Gay lovers must hide their
relationship from their families and everyone else, or they will fall
victim to the Vichy persecution of
the “third sex.” A young Jewish
girl looking to escape the clutches
of the Third Reich—after seeing
her parents and sister brutally slain
while attempting to make their way
to England—is taken in by Jean
and Philippe, who nurse her back
to health.
Jean, a childhood friend of the
young girl's, tells her he loves her
—if only to give her the will to
survive. Philipe becomes jealous
and all his insecurities come to the
surface. However, the two give
her shelter, a job, protection, and a
new identity as an employee of his
family's laundry business.
Depicted with genuine emotion,
the story of the three is told mainly
through the eyes of Jean. Despite
the ever-increasing Nazi presence, the trio manages to live safely
together for a while. Of course,
everything takes a turn for the
worse when Jean's brother Jacques
(Nicholas Gob), the black sheep
of the family, returns from jail for
smoking marijuana.
Jacques brings unwanted attention
into their lives. While he
realizes that Jean is the only person
who loves him unconditionally,
they do not see eye to eye on most
things. Jacques sells the addresses
of Jews who haven't picked up
their laundry, so that their houses
can be robbed. He becomes a Nazi
collaborator and falls madly in love
with Sara.
After Jean and Jacques parents
announce that they're leaving the
business to Jean, Jacques is filled with envy, jealousy, and rage. Their relationship
is strained when Jacques learns that
his brother is a homosexual. Jean begs his
brother not to stop loving him and does his
best to convince him that his homosexuality
was not a choice. In a rash move to prove his
superiority, Jacques unleashes a devastating
chain of events that will change all of their
lives forever.
Jacques asks his partner in crime to have
Jean arrested, held in jail for one day, then
bought to the Laundromat. The Gestapo
would tell his parents that Jacques was the
one responsible for saving Jean from going
into the concentration camp. This heroic act
would have Jacques parents seeing him in a
new light. This would also make Sara fall
in love with him. This plan bites Jacques in
the ass and disgraces the whole family after
the Gestapo arrives and announces that Jean
has been exposed as a member of the “third
sex” and is accused of having an affair with
a Nazi soldier.
Jean is tortured, beaten, and is forced to
look at pictures of the Nazi soldier who
committed suicide and whom has a bullet
in his temple. Jacques does get the family
business along with other dirty dealings.
Jean's spirit and strength is broken when he
learns that it was his beloved brother who
turned him in. Sara watches in horror as her
homosexual protector is forced into a Nazi
labor camp.
Sara witnesses the death of Philipe after he
tries to escape being arrested as an agent of
the resistance. Jacques is relentless in getting
Sara to marry him and be a part of his life.
She agrees to marry him to keep her cover
and to help rescue Jean from the concentration
camp. At the concentration camp, Jean
makes a friend wearing a pink triangle and
who's being “re-educated.” After witnessing
the death of his friend, Jean puts on the man's
uniform bearing the pink triangle and tells
the Nazi Guards to kill him too. They send
him to Dachaut, a camp that was become
known as the epitome of evil.
A Love to Hide is a haunting, gut-wrenching,
and heart-breaking love story that celebrates
the tenaciousness of the spirit and
serves as a reminder to stand up for ourselves
no matter what it takes. The experience of
the homosexuals was arguably the worst
of all the victims of the Nazis. The few
who survived could still be prosecuted in
Germany and France many years after they
were liberated from the camps. The relief
effort ignored their plight and only a few
survived long enough for their stories to be
appreciated, decades later.
The 1871 German law that criminalized
homosexuality was revised by the Nazis
in 1935 and remained on the books in East
Germany until 1967. The Nazi version of
the law was repealed in West Germany in
1969 but not eliminated until 1973. Freedom
for Gay men was finally acheived after
reunification.
The performances are commanding. Jean
and Philippe play off of each other with extraordinary
chemistry and Sarah's profile in
courage carries every scene she's in. Director
Christian Faure shows every cruel, heartless,
and evil act -- along with the atrocities and
devastation that war brings. The cinematography
is refined and the visual affects leaves
you in total awe. We witness the horrors that
Gay people faced in the not-to-long ago past.
The film also pays strong attention to details,
as the Nazi occupation of France is rendered
in all its infamous glory.